Posted by: Chris Maloney | June 15, 2012

How Much Vitamin D Do You Need To Take To Maintain Bone Health?

20/2.2011 vitamin D

20/2.2011 vitamin D (Photo credit: julochka)

Warning:  math and chemistry discussion (with units!)

If you’ve been living under a rock, you’ve missed the new fad that vitamin D can solve all your health problems.  Just keep taking more.  But then occasionally we hear things about people like Gary Null taking too much (his supplement was off by a factor of ten).

So how much vitamin D should you take?  Short answer, we don’t know.  The problem is that the amount you take and the amount you absorb are different.  But in general, a ball park estimate for Vitamin D would be (much handwaving here):

About (maybe) 100 IU for every 1-2 nmol/L in your blood.

So what’s the optimum dose for nmol/L of vitamin D in your blood?  The cutoff is 20 nmol/L.  Below that you’re deficient.  To get that amount of vitamin D:

100 IU = 1 nmol/L (conservative here, because we don’t want deficiency)

400IU (the current Recommended Dietary Intake) = 4 nmol/L  The new RDI 800 IU = 8 nmol/L.  To get the bare minimum to avoid rickets and deficiency, you need 2000 IU = 20 nmol/L.

Now, if your absorption is better, then you need less, but by the best standards we have, the current RDI from the U.S. government is not sufficient to maintain people at sufficient levels.  So, they’re estimating that your dietary intake will be sufficient to make up the difference.  But that’s not a safe assumption, because not everyone is sucking down quarts of milk these days.  Or getting out into the sun to activate their vitamin D.

What about the upper range?  Again, someone taking 100,000 IU of vitamin D is going to end up with theoretically 1,000 nmol/L in their blood.  That’s what made Null sick.  It’s way too much.

Somewhere between 30 nmol/L (3,000 IU daily) and 80 nmol/L (8,000 IU daily) have not been shown to kill you.  But we also have scant evidence of any health benefits at that level.  Until the advocates do the studies to show that this much vitamin D doesn’t just suppress your hormonal response, we’ve only got evidence for something less.

Oh, and before you send me comments about how your particular brand of exotic coral reef derived plankton Vitamin D is better/nontoxic, have a look at the abstract below.

I hope this was helpful.  If you want to change your Vitamin D levels, please talk to your doctor.  Don’t use a blog post to determine your health.  That’s just loco.


Tell me what you think!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: